Rebel Float Pumpkin Spice Grilled Cheese

This bold autumn grilled cheese is all about cozy vibes and playful twists. Creamy pumpkin spice pairs with gooey cheese inside buttery golden bread while a vanilla ice cream cream soda float takes you straight back to retro diner days. Whenever fall rolls around my kitchen smells like toasting brioche and warm spices — my signal it is time for this treat. The perfect blend of nostalgia and seasonal comfort.

The first time I made this it was just for myself on an October afternoon but now it is a must for cozy movie nights or Sunday brunches with friends. Everyone lights up when the floats arrive alongside the sandwiches.

Ingredients

• Thick-cut brioche or sourdough bread: brings richness and structure to hold everything together Seek out a loaf with a tender but sturdy crumb
• Unsalted butter: gives that classic golden crunch Try to pick the highest quality for best flavor
• Canned pumpkin puree: adds velvety texture and autumnal richness Opt for pure pumpkin not pumpkin pie filling
• Pumpkin pie spice: creates instant coziness A fresh blend with cinnamon nutmeg and cloves makes all the difference
• Maple syrup: balances savory cheese with a subtle sweetness Real maple syrup is worth it here
• Pinch of salt: sharpens flavors and keeps the sandwich from tasting too sweet Try flaky sea salt if you have it
• Sharp white cheddar cheese: melts beautifully while providing big flavor Always buy cheese in blocks and slice it yourself for max melt
• Creamy Havarti or mozzarella cheese: brings gooey stretchiness that pairs well with mild pumpkin notes
• Cream soda: provides that fizzy retro vibe Choose a quality craft soda if you can or classic supermarket brands work too
• Vanilla ice cream scoops: turn the soda into a dessert experience Real vanilla bean versions are extra special
• Ground cinnamon or nutmeg for garnish (optional): Paints fragrant layers over the float

Instructions

Mix the Pumpkin Spread:

In a small bowl stir together canned pumpkin puree pumpkin pie spice maple syrup and a pinch of salt until completely smooth No lumps should remain for the silkiest bite

Assemble the Sandwiches:

Spread the creamy pumpkin mixture all over two slices of bread Top each with two slices of sharp cheddar cheese and one slice of Havarti or mozzarella Close each sandwich with the rest of the bread Press gently to secure everything together

Butter the Outside:

Using a butter knife or small spatula generously coat the outer sides of the sandwiches with softened unsalted butter Cover every edge for a perfect crisp

Grill to Golden Perfection:

Heat a non stick skillet over medium heat Once hot place the sandwiches in the pan Cook for three to four minutes per side pressing gently with a spatula Turn only when the first side is deeply golden and crispy Watch for any oozing cheese or pumpkin that wants to escape

Make the Cream Soda Float:

Fill two tall glasses with one cup of chilled cream soda each Gently lower a scoop of vanilla ice cream into each so it floats at the top For even more aroma sprinkle a hint of cinnamon or nutmeg over each float

Serve Immediately:

Slice the pumpkin spice grilled cheese diagonally for classic diner style and enjoy piping hot next to your cream soda floats

Save to Pinterest

My top pick is always the white cheddar which gets irresistibly gooey and sharp The first bite is pure golden crunch followed by melty cheese and maple pumpkin I remember the time I made this for a fall birthday and the float made everyone laugh — we felt like kids with grown up taste

Storage Tips

Store sandwiches ungrilled in the fridge wrapped tightly for up to twenty four hours For cooked leftovers wrap in foil and reheat in a toaster oven for crispiness Floats should be made right before serving to keep the ice cream from melting

Ingredient Substitutions

Use cinnamon swirl bread if you want extra warm spice Try Monterey jack or fontina if you cannot find Havarti Non dairy butter and plant based cheese will work for a vegan version Swap ginger ale for cream soda when you want less sweetness

Serving Suggestions

Serve this as a quirky brunch centerpiece with fresh apple slices Pair with sweet potato fries or arugula salad for a full meal Cut sandwiches into strips and dip into the float for extra fun

Cultural and Historical Context

Grilled cheese and soda floats are classic American comfort foods This recipe gives them a playful fall update using pumpkin spice and maple echoes of harvest flavors and cozy family gatherings

Seasonal Adaptations

Enjoy with these seasonal swaps Sub fresh roasted pumpkin for canned if available Mix a little apple butter into the pumpkin spread for more depth Top the float with candied ginger or a sprinkle of crushed nuts

Three Helpful Notes

Always use freshly grated cheese for best melt No pre shredded blends Press the sandwiches gently but do not flatten or you will lose the gooey middle Serve the float with tall spoons and straws for the retro soda shop vibe

Success Stories

Kids will love the sweet creamy floats while adults appreciate the savory sweet contrast Every time I serve this at casual get togethers it disappears fast with lots of smiles

Freezer Meal Conversion

Assemble sandwiches without grilling then freeze flat in a single layer Once firm transfer to a freezer bag Grill straight from frozen for five to six minutes per side

Save to Pinterest

Enjoy every bite while hot with frosty floats on the side. Cozy flavors and comfort for fall memories.

Common Recipe Questions

→ What bread works best for this grilled cheese?

Thick-cut brioche or sturdy sourdough provides the best structure and flavor for the pumpkin-spiced filling.

→ Can I substitute cheese types in the sandwich?

Yes, creamy mozzarella or extra Havarti work well if sharp cheddar is unavailable. Mix for best flavor.

→ Is it possible to make the float dairy-free?

Swap in your favorite non-dairy ice cream to create a lactose-free version of the cream soda float.

→ How can I add more autumn flavor?

Try using cinnamon swirl bread or sprinkle extra pumpkin pie spice into the filling for a bolder taste.

→ What pairs well as a side with this meal?

Sweet potato fries or a refreshing arugula salad complement the savory and sweet flavors beautifully.